Guest
|
|
Posted: Dec. 29 2004,15:41 |
|
It seems appropriate to me that the best critique of the UN's approach to the Millennium Development Goals comes from the first woman from East or Central Africa to earn a Ph.D. who is now the first specialist in development to win the Nobel Peace Prize, Wangari Maathai. In her speech at the UN she insists that development must be based on peace and democracy with human rights. This issue of peace is completely missing from the UN's Millennium Development Goals, as described in the CPNN report I made on this year's NGO Conference at the UN.
Several years ago, when still working at the UN I had a long conversation with a man who had been the UN Resident Representative in about a dozen different African countries. I asked him point blank, "In your experience has development aid increased or decreased the amount of war and violent conflict in Africa." He did not hesitate to respond, "On balance it has increased violence."
Nor does development aid usually help bring democracy. Instead, development aid, especially by the most powerful countries such as the US and France, tends to go to the "haves" rather than the "have-nots." For example, when I was working for a culture of peace programme in Mozambique, I went to the US ambassador to ask for funding. He replied that all their funding (tens of millions of dollars!) was already committed. The money associated with the Republican Party was going to the Renamo Party and the money associated with the Democratic Party was going to the Frelimo Party. And you could see it. The top politicians of both parties were corrupted by the money and drove around Maputo in armored limousines, protected from coming into contact with the poor. The US was reproducing its own corrupt 2-party system in Mozambique and in a position to influence whichever party came to power.
The awarding of the Nobel Peace Prize to Wangari Maathai this year can open many doors - and one of the most important is to shed light on the nature of development aid, including that of the United Nations.
|